What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: On Running & More — May 22, 2026

We opened this Amazon Mystery Box on May 22nd, and honestly, it was a lean pull — six items total, with five heading straight to our store bins. But that sixth item? That's where the story lives.

The Star: On Cloud X 3 Training Shoe in Fawn/Magnet at Nordstrom, Size 8.5

On Running makes some of the most sought-after performance shoes on the market right now, and the On Cloud X 3 Training Shoe in Fawn/Magnet at Nordstrom, Size 8.5 is no exception. Retail: $188.99. Brand new. That Fawn/Magnet colorway is understated and genuinely pretty — the kind of shoe that works at the gym and looks good grabbing coffee after. If you wear an 8.5, this one's already waiting for you here in Hot Springs.

The rest of the box? Five bin-labeled pieces heading to our store bins for resale — no marquee names, but that's how these mystery boxes go sometimes. You're essentially paying for the chase, and this time the chase delivered one clean, high-value win.

Total estimated retail on the full box came in at $258.99, with nearly all of that sitting in one sealed shoe box. Not every Amazon Mystery Box we open swings for the fences across the board — but landing a pair of On Clouds makes this one a quiet win in our book.