What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Cards Against Humanity & More — May 22, 2026

Not every box we crack open here in Hot Springs is a home run, and honestly? That's kind of the deal with an Amazon Mystery Box. Sometimes the box is more of a bunt. This one came in with a modest retail value, but what it lacked in size it made up for in party-ready personality.

The Star of This Box: Two Copies of Cards Against Humanity

Yep, two sealed copies of Cards Against Humanity — the Main Game — landed in this box. At $21.75 each, that's nearly $44 in retail value from a single game title alone. These are the real deal: 4+ players, 30+ minutes of increasingly questionable life choices, and a whole lot of laughs. Whether you're stocking up for a gift or finally replacing the copy your friends "borrowed," these don't last long on our shelves.

Beyond those two, the rest of the box was mostly bin-labeled items — over twenty pieces heading straight into our store bins for anyone who loves digging for a deal.

Was this box a blockbuster? Not exactly. Total retail value came in around $158, and the bulk of that was bin inventory. But the two party games alone made it worth the open, and that's the honest truth about treasure hunting — sometimes the gold is just two boxes of Cards Against Humanity and a good attitude.

Swing by Deals Down Under in Hot Springs and grab one before they disappear. And if you want to roll the dice yourself, our Amazon Mystery Boxes are available in-store — you never quite know what's coming next.