What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: B&H Publishing Group & More — May 16, 2026

We opened this Amazon Mystery Box on a Friday evening and honestly? It made us laugh. Not every box is a home run, and at $213.45 estimated retail across 23 items, this one was solidly mid — but in a charming, "what even is Amazon inventory sometimes" kind of way. Here in Hot Springs, we love a box that keeps you guessing.

The Star of the Box: Six Cases of B & H Publishing Group 63429 Commun Fellowship Cup Prefilled Juice Wafer Box Of 100

Yes, you read that right. Six sealed boxes of B & H Publishing Group 63429 Commun Fellowship Cup Prefilled Juice Wafer Box Of 100 — each retailing at $19.41. That's over $116 in prefilled communion cups alone. If your church, ministry, or small congregation goes through these, this is genuinely a great find. Each box holds 100 cups, prefilled with juice and a wafer. Ready to go, no prep needed. We didn't see that one coming.

The Practical Find: 2-7/8" Heavy-Duty Wood Screws 500 pcs with T30 Free Bit

Rounding out the notable items is a 500-piece set of 2-7/8" Heavy-Duty Wood Screws 500 pcs with T30 Free Bit at $16.99 retail. A solid score for any DIYer or contractor. Five hundred screws and a free T30 bit — that's just a useful thing to have around.

The rest of the box was bulk bin material — plus a couple dozen bin-labeled items heading straight to our store bins for resale. Nothing glamorous, but nothing goes to waste. That's the thing about an Amazon Mystery Box: even the quiet ones fill the shelves.