What We Found in an Amazon Mystery Box: Asst car parts set & More — May 17, 2026

Some boxes have a theme. This one did not. And honestly? That's kind of the charm of an Amazon Mystery Box. You never know if you're going to pull auto supplies or afternoon snacks, and this particular box pulled both.

The Wildcard Winner: Asst Car Parts Set

The Asst Car Parts Set came in at $40.00 retail and it's the kind of item that either has your name on it or it doesn't. If you're a DIY garage person here in Hot Springs, this one's worth a look — sealed, brand new, ready to go.

On the completely opposite end of the spectrum, we pulled eight boxes of Daiya DELUXE WHITE CHEDDAR STYLE VEGGIE CHEEZY MAC at $3.99 each. Eight. That's a lot of plant-based comfort food arriving all at once, and we're not complaining. Great grab for anyone doing dairy-free.

There were also three sets of Nail Art Accessories Charm Set - Red and Gold with Rhinestones by Nailorin — $8.99 each, sealed, and genuinely pretty. Red and gold with rhinestones is a vibe. Someone's going to love those.

And rounding out the notable finds: one Immune Support Blueberry Iced Tea 12 Pack from The Ryl Tea Co. at $14.99. Functional iced tea in a mystery box feels very 2025. We'll take it.

The rest of the haul — plus dozens more bin-labeled items heading to our store bins — rounds out a box that clocked in around $403 in estimated retail value. Not our flashiest pull, but there's genuinely something for everyone stuffed in here.